Amajuba District Municipality announces next steps after mayor's election ruled unlawful

The Amajuba District Municipality (Newcastle) has formally acknowledged a judgment delivered by the Pietermaritzburg High Court that declared the election of its mayor and deputy mayor invalid, reaffirming its commitment to the rule of law and democratic governance.

In a media statement, the municipality said it “respects the authority and independence of the judiciary” and remains committed to “upholding the rule of law and the principles of democratic governance.”

The Pietermaritzburg High Court ruled that the appointments of IFP's Thembelihle Mthembu as mayor of Amajuba District Municipality, and Isaac Shaka Sithole as his deputy are unlawful.

Thirteen Amajuba District Municipality councillors launched a high court application on May 23, 2025, challenging the legality of a council meeting held on May 20, 2025. This meeting resulted in the election of Mthembu and Sithole.

The applicants sought to have the election declared unlawful and all decisions made during that meeting set aside. The municipality and its council opposed the application.

The municipality said while the judgment presents institutional challenges, it was an opportunity “to reaffirm our dedication to transparency, accountability, and proper procedure in all matters of the council”.

The municipality sought to reassure residents and stakeholders that the court ruling would not affect daily operations or essential services.

“We wish to assure our residents and stakeholders that service delivery remains our top priority,” the statement said, adding that the administration and council “will continue to function effectively, ensuring that essential services are not disrupted during this period.”

Following the judgment, which upheld the previous status quo, the municipality confirmed that Councillor Mthembu has resumed his role as acting mayor.

According to the statement, this step was taken in line with the court’s decision and existing legal arrangements.

To address the implications of the ruling, the municipality announced that it will convene a Special Council Meeting “to formally consider the judgment and determine the appropriate way forward in compliance with the law.”

The municipality also appealed for stability and unity during the transition period, calling on “all councillors, officials, and community members to remain calm and united as we navigate this process.” It stressed that the collective focus should remain on “building a municipality that serves its people with integrity, fairness, and resilience.”

At the same time, the municipality expressed appreciation for the outgoing leadership. It acknowledged “the work done by both Mthembu and Sithole who held the positions of the mayor and deputy mayor respectively, over the past months.”

The statement noted that under their leadership, “the municipality has seen progress in strengthening service delivery, enhancing community engagement, and driving initiatives that reflect our commitment to the people of Amajuba District.”

It added that their “dedication and hard work have left a positive impact,” and thanked them for their continued contribution alongside all members of council.

For more stories from The Mercury, click the link THE MERCURY